top of page
Search

Your Managers Aren't Disengaged. They Were Spent.

Writer: Eric Jones
Eric Jones
Oct 8
2 min read

Your managers are not quietly quitting. They are quietly paying an organizational bill.

Every new priority, vacancy, system change, difficult conversation, and executive promise gets routed through the manager layer. The invoice is structural: more responsibility, less authority, thinner support, and no recovery time. Calling the result a morale problem sends the bill back to the person carrying it.

Gallup found manager engagement fell from 31% in 2022 to 22% in 2025. The sharpest single-year drop was 27% to 22%, while individual contributors held flat. The manager engagement premium is gone. Managers explain roughly 70% of team-engagement variance. Best-practice organizations sustain 79% manager engagement because manager development is business strategy, not an HR program.

Notice

  • Treat withdrawal as a signal. Ask, “What are you carrying that nobody has funded?”

  • Map invisible work: emotional labor, escalation, coordination, and rework.

  • Compare accountability with authority. A manager without decision rights is not unmotivated. They are under-enabled.

3D clayart illustration of a depleted manager surrounded by tasks while unnecessary demands are removed

Repair

Gallup’s H1 2026 data puts U.S. engagement at 31%, with 18% actively disengaged and roughly $2 trillion lost annually in productivity. The answer is not another motivational campaign.

  • Remove one recurring demand before adding resilience training.

  • Clarify what stops, who decides, and how emergencies escalate.

  • Build recovery into the workweek, not after the workweek breaks people.

Deloitte’s UK-based estimate adds a financial warning: poor workplace mental health costs employers £51 billion annually, with presenteeism the largest cost line. Every £1 invested returns £4.70, rising to £6.30 when intervention is early and organization-wide.

Practice

Resilience-based leadership becomes credible when it changes daily behavior.

  • Run a weekly “load, control, recovery” check-in.

  • Create peer spaces where managers can think, not merely vent.

  • Track manager engagement, absence, regretted attrition, and workload alongside team results.

A published LeaderFactor customer story shows what sustained practice can produce. A $4.8 billion U.S. health system reported 1,948% second-year ROI, about $20.50 returned per $1 invested, and approximately $883,000 in avoided replacement costs from about seven fewer exits in one division.

That is the logic behind ROR: Return on Relationship: performance becomes more durable when relationships, clarity, and human capacity are treated as operating assets.

What structural bill are your managers paying for free?

What would change if resilience included authority, recovery, and relationship, not another request to endure?

3D clayart illustration of Roxanne Derhodge practicing a calm, connected leadership check-in with managers

Sources

 
 
 

Comments

© 2035 by Roxanne Dehodge.

​

bottom of page